July 14, 2025 | Rick Wargo
Overdraft programs offer members the relief of avoiding nonsufficient funds (NSF) items, and there is often a fee for that convenience. For credit unions, these fees can generate significant income that supports a range of services and member benefits.
But navigating the waters of consumer disclosures, terms and conditions, and program structure can challenge even the most seasoned sailor. And lately, the forecast for overdraft programs calls for rough seas.
In this article, we chart a course through the latest developments to help you steer clear of hidden hazards.
Overdraft Credit Regulation: Calm After the Storm
The regulatory storm surrounding overdraft credit has officially passed—for now. The CFPB’s proposed rule would have essentially capped overdraft fees at $5 for institutions with more than $10 billion in assets. While most credit unions fall below that threshold, the concern was that larger institutions could influence market expectations across the board.
However, both the U.S. House and Senate passed resolutions under the Congressional Review Act to nullify the regulation, and the President signed the measure on May 12, 2025. With that, the rule was effectively dead in the water. For the time being, credit unions can sail in calmer seas when it comes to regulatory caps on overdraft fees.
Class Action Litigation: Rough Waters Ahead
Despite clearer skies on the regulatory front, ongoing class action lawsuits continue to stir up stormy seas for overdraft programs. In particular, legal claims are increasingly focusing on how financial institutions calculate and disclose account balances used to determine overdraft fees—specifically, whether they rely on the available balance or ledger balance.
At the heart of these lawsuits is the argument that disclosures are insufficiently clear, creating potential violations of the Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA), Regulation E, and state laws regarding breach of contract and unfair or deceptive acts and practices.
Case in Point: Tims v. LGE Community Credit Union
In a noteworthy case from the Eleventh Circuit, plaintiff Carol Tims brought a class action suit against LGE Community Credit Union. Tims claimed that the credit union assessed overdraft fees based on her available balance, despite her ledger balance being sufficient to cover the transaction.
LGE used Regulation E’s Model Form A-9 for its Opt-In Agreement, which is standard and compliant practice. The form includes language stating, “An overdraft occurs when you do not have enough money in your account to cover a transaction but we pay it anyway.” (12 C.F.R. Part 1005, Appendix A, A-9 Model Consent Form to Overdraft Services)
Tims argued that the language of the Opt-In Agreement was unclear and could be interpreted to mean either the available or ledger balance. LGE countered that its account agreement and funds availability disclosure clarified the use of the available balance. But the court wasn’t persuaded by either side and ultimately ruled in favor of Tims.
The court found that the opt-in disclosure was ambiguous because it could describe either the available or the ledger balance calculation method for unsettled debits. As a result, the court determined that it is plausible that the notice did not describe the overdraft service in a clear and readily understandable way, further concluding that Tims may not have had a reasonable opportunity to affirmatively consent to LGE’s overdraft service. (Tims v. LGE Community Credit Union, 935 F.3d 1228, at 1243)
This decision is troubling for two key reasons:
- Limitations of Model Form A-9: The model form was intentionally designed to be simple, without delving into technical account mechanics. But that simplicity now raises questions about its adequacy.
- Erosion of the EFTA Safe Harbor: If courts can rule against credit unions even when they rely on official model forms, the legal “safe harbor” becomes murky at best—leaving credit unions adrift in uncertainty.
Charting a Safer Course
So where can credit unions find safer waters? Consider the following steps:
- Clarify your disclosures. Ensure your membership and account agreements clearly define the balance calculation method used for overdraft decisions.
- Revise opt-in language. Modify the standard language in Model Form A-9 to remove ambiguity. For example:
“An overdraft occurs when you do not have a sufficient available balance in your account to cover a transaction, but we pay it anyway.”
- Enhance Truth-in-Savings disclosures. Include a definition of available balance wherever overdraft fees are discussed.
Taking these steps can help your credit union avoid legal shoals and maintain a steady course.
Final Thoughts: Stay the Course with Confidence
While the regulatory storm over CFPB’s overdraft rule has passed, treacherous waters remain. Class action lawsuits—especially those challenging the clarity of overdraft disclosures—pose ongoing risks. The Tims case illustrates that even credit unions following model regulatory forms aren’t immune from legal challenges, and the erosion of the safe harbor leaves little margin for error.
To stay on course, credit unions must steer proactively. Review and revise your overdraft disclosures, clarify your account agreements, and don’t assume that regulatory model forms offer full protection. As with any voyage, preparation is key.
If your credit union is navigating these issues, or simply wants to ensure smoother sailing ahead, Compliance 4 Credit Unions is here to help. Contact us today at 717-580-1450 or Send a Message to schedule a consultation.
We’ll help you chart the best course forward—away from legal reefs and toward clearer, safer waters.

