ETF Disputes - Calendar deadline

Junk Fees: Still a Compliance Concern Regardless of a Shifting Environment

December 16, 2024 | Rick Wargo

As 2024 draws to a close, the Compliance 4 Credit Unions (C4CU) team wishes you Season’s Greetings!

But just like Santa Claus leaves coal for the naughty, credit unions will continue to face pressure on ‘junk fees’. The transition to a new administration may bring shifts in regulatory priorities, but addressing junk fees is likely to remain a significant compliance concern. With that said, let’s take a closer look at what junk fees are, how they’re regulated, and how credit unions can mitigate their risks.

What Are Junk Fees?

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) defines junk fees as unnecessary charges that inflate the cost of goods or services without adding meaningful value for consumers. This perspective was clearly outlined in the Winter 2023 Supervisory Highlights, which also revealed the CFPB’s reliance on examinations and enforcement actions to identify and address such fees.

The concept of junk fees is broad and far-reaching. Examples include:

  • “Pay to Pay” or Convenience Fees: Often applied without clear justification.
  • Excessive Late Fees: Charges beyond reasonable caps, such as mortgage late fees exceeding programmed limits or fees imposed after vehicle repossession.
  • Authorized Positive-Settle Negative (APSN) Overdraft Fees: Fees triggered when a transaction is authorized with sufficient funds but posts after an intervening transaction reduces the balance.
  • Payment Processing Fees: Such as those applied to school lunch programs without adequate disclosure or justification.

Regulatory Framework

The CFPB evaluates junk fees under its authority to regulate unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices (UDAAP). Specifically, a fee is considered unfair if it:

  1. Causes or is likely to cause substantial injury to the consumer.
  2. Is not reasonably avoidable.
  3. Is not outweighed by benefits to consumers or competition.

For example, the CFPB considers authorized positive-settle negative (APSN) overdraft fees to be inherently unfair. These fees occur when a consumer’s account has a positive available balance at the time a debit or ATM transaction is authorized, but an intervening transaction – such as a check or automated payment – posts before the debit or ATM transaction, resulting in an overdraft.

Consumers often cannot anticipate these charges, as they reasonably assume no fee will be incurred when a transaction is approved with sufficient funds. The resulting confusion creates an unavoidable injury, which the CFPB argues is not offset by any benefit to the consumer or competition. This reasoning has formed the basis for multiple CFPB consent orders against financial institutions.

In addition to the CFPB, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has also entered the conversation, proposing a junk fee rule in October 2023. If finalized, this rule would classify hidden fees or undisclosed costs as unfair or deceptive. While federal credit unions are outside FTC jurisdiction, state-chartered credit unions do fall under the FTC’s authority.

Risk Mitigation Strategies for Credit Unions

To reduce the risk of enforcement actions related to junk fees, credit unions can take proactive steps, including:

  • Eliminating APSN Transactions: CFPB guidance states these transactions cannot be adequately disclosed, making them a high-risk area.
  • Justifying Fees: Be prepared to identify the costs your fees offset and ensure they provide clear value.
  • Accurate Disclosures: Disclose what you do and do what you disclose. Align your disclosures with actual practices. Clear, transparent terms and conditions are your best defense against compliance risk.

Looking Ahead

The new administration may bring changes to regulatory priorities, but junk fees are likely to remain a focus at both federal and state levels. If federal efforts shift, some states have already signaled their intent to strengthen consumer protections independently. States such as Massachusetts and California have implemented “all-in” price rules, and legislation addressing junk fees is under consideration in several others. Credit unions should remain vigilant about state-level enforcement activity, as attorneys general in many states hold UDAAP authority and may take a more active role in addressing junk fees.

As we prepare to navigate these evolving compliance challenges, C4CU remains dedicated to supporting credit unions every step of the way. Let us assist you with your compliance concerns. Contact us today at 717-580-1450 or Send a Message.

Once again, from all of us at C4CU, we wish you Happy Holidays and a prosperous New Year!